A Reply in the Eleventh Year

For ten years, a man wrote one letter to himself every year.
Naturally, he never received a reply during that time.
In the eleventh year, when a reply arrived for the first time, he fled the house.
What kind of reply did he receive?
Question your assumptions, one by one.
Ask the AI your own questions and uncover the truth behind the mystery.
View Hints
Hints
Use as many hints as you need, one at a time.
Hint 1
Writing a letter does not necessarily mean posting it.
Hint 2
He was writing to himself—but himself at what point in his life?
Hint 3
The man wanted to leave the house.
Hint 4
The man was not free to leave the house of his own accord.
Hint 5
The reply was written by someone who learned of his situation only after reading his letters.
Hint 6
He did not flee because the reply threatened or frightened him.
Hint 7
The reply contained an offer to help him get out of the house.
Check the Answer
Answer
It was a reply from the housekeeper offering to help him escape: “Let's get out of here together.”
The man was being held captive by his family. He had kept writing letters to his future self, who would one day be free. The housekeeper read the letters, learned of his situation, and wrote back to offer her help.
He trusted the reply and escaped from the house with the housekeeper's help. He did not flee because the reply frightened him; the reply finally gave him an opportunity to escape.
Explanation
The man had not posted the letters. He had hidden them in his room. Since he had not sent them to anyone, it was only natural that no reply had come.
In the eleventh year, his family found the letters and threw them all in the bin. The housekeeper read them while clearing it out. Until then, she had been told that the man was ill and recuperating.
The housekeeper folded her reply up small and hid it in a slit in the bread served with his meal. His family brought the meal to him as usual, and he found the reply when he broke open the bread.
That night, after the family had gone to sleep, the housekeeper took the key and unlocked his room.
For example: “Had the man been posting the letters to his own home?” — “No.” “Was the reply from someone helping him escape?” — “Yes.” The fact that he fled after reading a reply does not mean the reply frightened him. It was what made escape possible.
If the solution makes sense to you, add your vote. One vote per browser.


