Beginner

The Four Who Gave Their Names

New here? How to play

Four people who knew one another well, both by face and by name, were having a discussion in the same well-lit room.

Yet every time one of them spoke, they gave their name.

This helped someone who never entered the room. Why?

Let’s unravel your preconceptions, one by one.

View Hints

Hints

Take it little by little, just as much as you need.

Hint 1

That person needed to know what was said during the discussion.

Hint 2

Only the sound of the discussion reached that person.

Hint 3

That person could not tell who was speaking just by hearing their voices.

Check the Answer

Answer

So that someone listening only to the audio of the meeting could tell who was speaking.

Explanation

The discussion was being recorded without video.

Someone would later listen to the recording to write the minutes. That person did not know the four people's voices and could not identify the speakers from the audio alone.

By saying their names before speaking, each person's name and words were recorded together, one after the other. This let the listener tell who had said what.

The four were not introducing themselves to one another. They were identifying themselves for someone who was not there.

Likes from everyone. One vote per browser.

Go to the problem list

Keep SOUP HOUR close

iPhone & iPad

Open this page in Safari, tap Share, then Add to Home Screen. If Open as Web App appears, turn it on, then tap Add.

Other browsers

Choose Install or Add to home screen in your browser menu if available. Otherwise, bookmark the site for quick access.

An internet connection is required.

© 2026 SOUP HOUR

Would you like to see the answer?

The solution is written below. If you want to think about it a little more, you can go back to the problem or the hints.